Happy to browse, not to buy
In retail, research shows that Australian consumers are happy to let agents find products but not buy them, said Wirth. A YouGov survey for payments company Adyen, published in July, found 64% of Australians have used AI assistants to “browse, compare or discover products”.1
The survey found that two-thirds of respondents (also 64%) feel uncomfortable letting AI complete a purchase for them. Just 5% are fully comfortable letting AI buy on its own.
“There’s a way to go,” said Wirth. “But what we’ve seen transpire in the last couple of years is that consumer perceptions can switch really, really quickly.”
Similar research showed that only 40% of Australians were prepared to use agents for shopping, said Moore, citing a survey from the middle of this year. This reservation is not shared by our Asia-Pacific neighbours: In Singapore, 59% are prepared to use agents, and in China it’s 87%, said Moore.
“You could say that Australia is cautious, but caution is probably warranted in this journey,” said Moore. “‘Cautious but ready’ is a great place to be, I think, and that’s where Australia sits relative to the rest of the world.”
The pace of change is not dictated by technology, which is arriving at speed. Last week, OpenAI announced ChatGPT Wallet with Mastercard, Visa and Amex. Shoppers approve purchases with biometrics, such as Face ID, and the agent pays with a token rather than the card itself.
CommBank and Mastercard completed Australia’s first authorised agentic transactions earlier this year. CommBank has also written principles for agentic commerce with five other banks, including Bank of America and NatWest.2
Australian consumers will move once they have trust that the agent will buy the right product, in the correct colour and size, at an affordable price. The catch is that trust is earned when things don’t go perfectly, said Teas. “All of the work in payments is in the unhappy path.”
Teas said disputes traditionally go one of two ways. In one, the customer says they didn’t make the purchase, which is simple to resolve. In the other, the customer made the purchase but questions the goods. These are rarer but cost several times as much to resolve. An agent, however, adds a third question: Was this what the customer actually wanted?
Moore said Mastercard’s answer is “verifiable intent”. The details of what the customer asked to buy need to travel with the transaction, so every party can check that the purchase matches the request. If something goes wrong, the record shows whether the merchant, the bank or the agent made the mistake.
For now, the merchant or the card issuer still carries the cost of a dispute, depending on its type. However, Mastercard would look at shifting that cost if agents or the AI models behind them start causing serious problems, said Moore.
Another obstacle to trust is the youth of generative AI brands such as ChatGPT and Claude. They lack the years of reliability that banks have built up. Wirth contrasted the new players with CommBank. “We’re all familiar with CommBank. We’ve grown up with it. We’re asking consumers to take a leap of faith with brands and new technology that they’re not as familiar with.”