The Budget strategy: trying to hit a moving target
This Federal Budget is shaping as one of the most interesting in a long time, but what sort of Budget will it be? Will it be a reform Budget, aimed at lifting productivity? Will it be an austerity Budget, to keep inflation low? Will it be a crisis Budget, to buffer the economy from the global energy crisis? In our view, the Treasurer will try to achieve all these objectives.
The Treasurer would have started framing this Budget straight after the election win in May 2025. Since then, the landscape has been constantly shifting, making it hard to land a Budget narrative and fiscal strategy.
First, the Labor’s Party’s huge election win in May 2025 raised expectations that major economic reforms were on the way (including long overdue tax reform). The stated priorities have been to boost productivity, business investment and improve intergenerational fairness.
Second, the economy strengthened faster than expected, inflation picked up, and the RBA responded with back-to-back interest rate hikes. With a clear lack of spare capacity in the economy, calls to cut public spending got louder. Fighting inflation moved up the list of Budget priorities.
And finally, the Iran War threw a huge spanner into the Budget machine. It is still unclear what will happen next: peace, impasse or escalation, making it hard to frame a Budget response. Higher inflation is locked in, but the damage to economic growth is harder to gauge. National resilience will now be a clear Budget priority. But the Government will also feel pressure to dole out some more cost-of-living relief.
Achieving all of this in one Budget (major reform, big spending cuts, national resilience and supporting households) is quite the ask. We expect the government to try to thread the needle. To pull this off, they will need to meet several tests. This is what we think success looks like:
- Inflation & spending: They need to deliver major spending cuts (in the tens of billions); the savings can’t be cosmetic. And they need to show a large net improvement in the bottom line over the forward estimates and the medium term, relative to MYEFO.
- Tax & productivity: They need to announce substantive tax reforms. Major changes to CGT and negative gearing appear locked in. This will boost revenue but won’t shift the dial on productivity or housing affordability. Broader business or personal tax reform would deliver a true ‘reform Budget’.
- National resilience & cost of living: the Budget needs to include a clear plan (and allocate enough funding) to shore up our fuel security, including boosting oil stocks to at least 90 days. If further cost-of-living relief is delivered, it should be temporary and tightly targeted. A big splash risks driving inflation higher.