Hormuz flows remain crucial
The lower bound of $US70 a barrel is aligned to expectations or evidence of modest oil flows through the Strait.
We estimate that only 40-45% of pre-war oil flows are required to transit through the Strait of Hormuz to keep global oil and refined products unchanged.
This helps explain why oil markets are so quick to fall on any talk of a US-Iran deal. The reason that the Strait of Hormuz does not need to see pre-war levels of flow is because of the pipeline bypasses to the Strait of Hormuz, structurally lower Chinese oil imports and rising oil supply outside the Middle East.
The upper bound of $US100 a barrel reflects worries over inventory depletion and would be consistent with oil flows through the Strait of Hormuz being restricted.
We estimate that global oil markets still have around 15-20 weeks of stockpiles left based on our view that oil flows through the Strait are averaging about 30% of pre-war levels.
This is a highly contested view. Reports from the US government indicate that flows through the Strait are now averaging 40% of pre-war levels even without a US-Iran deal.
Meanwhile, ship-tracking and satellite imagery data are showing flows through the Strait as low as about 20% of pre-war levels, implying five to 11 weeks of oil and refined products before inventory depletion.
With satellite imagery over the Strait now less frequent due to pressure from the US government, oil markets are increasingly turning to secondary sources to confirm actual flows through the Strait.
Markets are justified in maintaining an oversupply bias given little evidence of global oil and refined product inventories declining.